Saturday, May 25, 2019

May 25 picks!

Hello everyone, 

We hope you had an interesting and productive week! Our team read the articles below: 

In this piece, Dr. Aarthi Gobinath (neuroscientist studying how stress differently affects male and female brains, @aarthigobinath) discusses the importance of including female subjects in research, and how the lack of consideration of sex differences explains sub par treatment results for women. 

A while ego, we highlighted in this blog the initiative "Request a Women Scientist", aiming to decrease the under representation of women in scientific panels, meetings and boards by providing a list of women scientists worldwide in all fields (if you are not on it, go join a pod!!). We were happy to read in this article that 11 months following its creation in January 2018, the database racked up a list of researchers from 174 different scientific disciplines in 133 countries. The progression of this initiative was recently published in PLoS Biology.

Receiving funding to perform research is one of the pillars of Academia. This article describes how language used in grant proposals is different between men and women applicants, and how that difference causes an imbalance resulting in men receiving more funding even when the review was blinded.

This thought-provoking commentary by Christine Middleton (associate editor at Physics Today)  reflects on the Katie Bouman/black hole controversy, and argues that the media focuses too much on looks when describing women scientists.

See you next week!

Tuesday, May 14, 2019

This week's picks

Hello everyone!

For those of you in academia, happy end of the semester!

If you're an educator, you may have noticed a disparity in your student population. This article by the Washington Post delves into the question as to why black and Latino students drop out of STEM majors at higher rates than their white peers. Perhaps one way to circumvent this disparate tendency is for institutions to take advantage of the Inclusive Excellence initiative by the Howard Hughes Medical Institute. This initiative allows for up to 30 schools to apply for grants to help promote diversity and inclusivity within their STEM programs. Is your institution on the list? If not, perhaps you can apply!

Speaking of inclusivity, there is always more to learn when it comes to how women fare in the STEM world. A recent paper highlighted that only 10% of children will depict a woman when asked to draw a scientist. Although 10% isn't particularly high, consider that in previous decades, this statistic was  only 1%! In order to combat this kind of perception, the organization 500 Women Scientists has compiled a database called Request a Woman Scientist so that women scientists will have more representation when it comes to public speaking events, consultations, or having their voice heard in the media. A recent study surveyed the women in this database, and one of the authors, Elizabeth McCullagh, sat down with Laboratory Equipment for an interview about this recent study investigating the effects Request a Woman Scientist has had.

We're always talking about inclusivity, and interventions to promote diversity in STEM, but what if there are unintended consequences, good or bad? This article in Psypost discusses potential negative consequences that come with these kinds of interventions.

Lastly, if you're looking to join an organization, consider checking out NEURONEXXT, a network for women in neuroscience.

Thanks for stopping by!

Wednesday, May 1, 2019

Our Picks for May 1, 2019

Show Me the Data: Studies on Bias and Sexual Harassment

Does Bias Training Fix Bias?

According to a new study in PNAS, bias training has limited effects on bias. They found that bias training aimed at preventing gender and racial bias had positive effects on attitudes of both men and women. However, bias training did not seem to have large effects on behavior, especially in men. This data suggests that if we want to get rid of bias, we need to do more than just one-off bias trainings!

Sexual Harassment Drives Women out of Physics

A recent study showed that almost 3/4 of undergraduate physics majors experience sexual harassment. They further show that experiencing sexual harassment decreases the likelihood that women stay in physics, decreases the feeling of belonging and increases imposter syndrome. For a good summary of the study and its context, see this piece by Julie Libarkin.

Thoughts, Observations, and News on Women in Science

Erika Jefferson asks where the black women leaders are in science. In 2017, only 5% of managerial STEM jobs were held by black women--we need to do better! One way to improve these numbers is to train black women in STEM to be leaders. And Jefferson has started Black Women in Science and Engineering (BWISE), a mentoring organization to do just that -- check it out!

Christine Liu asks whether the focus on imposter syndrome as a problem that's all in our heads is keeping us from changing what really causes it: a toxic environment.

The National Academy of Sciences has a plan to remove members convicted of sexual harassment.

Sunday, April 21, 2019

Our picks this week

In case you encounter anyone who says that gender bias/discrimination in science is a novel occurrence, and that it's never been an issue before, show them this article by the New York Times. This article outlines the experiences of senior women scientists at revered institutions, like the Salk Institute, who describe an atmosphere of marginalization and hostility throughout their years of service. Whether is was restricted access to resources, funding, or even the size of their laboratories, these women scientists found roadblock at every turn. Dr. Nancy Hopkins recalls a time where she was measuring the dimensions of the laboratories in her building to find that hers was 500 square feet smaller than the average male junior faculty and 1,500-4,500 square feet smaller than her fellow male full professors! When requesting more space (not that it should matter, but only 200 square feet!), the faculty member in charge refused to listen to her argument or view the data she collected. If you're getting push-back on something as simple as allocating appropriate laboratory space imagine the issues faced when trying to access larger scale resources like salary, funding, and promotions.

To read on about the difficulties women face in science and how it has evolved over the last few decades, click here. The number of overall women entering STEM fields is increasing, but these numbers waver when we consider minorities. There is also an issue with retention -- so even though we have made progress, there is still much to be done.

With the first image of a black hole plastered all over the internet, and even transformed into memes, you've probably encountered the name Dr. Katie Bouman, who played a significant role in making this major achievement possible. She entered the spotlight when her candid reaction to viewing a black hole for the first time went viral. It was an exciting eureka moment, meant to highlight an achievement that she and her team had worked so hard to develop. However, like everything on the internet, the narrative got twisted. The idea of the "lone genius" was ascribed to Dr. Bouman. This label is usually given to men -- the idea of that reclusive genius, working tirelessly in the corner by themselves, removed from the world, and solely responsible for their breakthroughs. As scientists, we all know this is rarely, if ever, the case. Science is possible through teamwork -- everyone contributes to a project, a hypothesis, a result. While this reality is rarely considered when a man has been labeled as a lone genius, when the internet attributed this breakthrough to Dr. Bouman, who "single-handedly" created the algorithm for the blackhole image, suddenly everyone is a detective and started questioning how much she was truly involved. Dr. Bouman never claimed to be solely responsible for the algorithm, and even publicly stated that it was a team effort. Still, she faces backlash, claims of "fraud" and threats. All of this because of a picture featuring her excitement about her work. Read on about this story here.

Don't forget to follow us on Twitter!

Saturday, April 13, 2019

Our picks for April 13, 2019

In this article, author Dr. Kate Nautiyal reflects on the results of a recent study published in PNAS reporting that half of new mothers leave full-time STEM work-force within a year of becoming a mother. The author considers the principal reasons this is the case and touches on the recent efforts taken by the NIH to push more family-friendly initiatives.
This article published in Forbes lists 10 strategies to promote the advancement of women in science. It summarizes the discussions that took place at the Symposium Highlighting Evidence-Based Interventions for Addressing the Underrepresentation of Women in Science, Engineering and Medicine held by the National Academy of Sciences, Engineering and Medicine (NASEM).
Chart of STEM jobs by demographic presented by, K Griffin, NAS presentation 2019
Last week, #ScienceTwitter was taken by storm by Dr.  Kay M. Tye's blog post, Gender Bias From A Woman In Science. In this article, Dr. Tye shares personal experiences and shocking comments from male colleagues she received throughout her career, proving the point that gender bias in science is very real. She also reflects on how to move forward and help improve the situation. A recommended read! In addition to Dr. Tye's blog post, Dr. May R. Berenbaum, editor-in-chief of the journal PNAS, looks back to the disparities between male and female contributions to the journal throughout history.
Moreover, #MeTooSTEM founder Dr. BethAnn McLaughlin gave an interview to The Guardian. She discusses the movement she launched, the solutions the scientific community should consider and how leadind the #MeTooSTEM movement impacted her career.

If you plan to organize or are involved in the organization of a scientific meeting in the near future, this guide might interest you. It walks you through the actions you can take to make the meeting as inclusive as possible. Similarly, the CUWFA (College and University Work-Life-Family Association) offers online resources to facilitate the integration of work and study with family/personal life at institutions of higher learning.

It is now accepted that preteen years are critical for girls, who often drop STEM-oriented classes around that age. The initiative Snap The Gap, led by LittleBits, Disney, UC Davis and MWM-CA, focuses on "instill every ten-year old girl in the United States with the courage, confidence, and tools needed to become tomorrow’s changemakers."
Duke's University news journal The Chronicle published an article on The Percentage Project, an initiative aiming to measure and describe the minority experiences in science and engineering. This project surveyed 164 Duke engineering and computer science students from a variety of backgrounds.The disparities between male and female students are striking, as shown in the figure below. 
2019-04-07-womenintech-selenaqian-online-01

Despite the lack of funding and recognition, black female founders constitute the fastest-growing group of entrepreneurs today. In this article, author Monique Greenwood chats with women of color in business about their personal stories and the reason of their success.
And we couldn't finish the week without mentioning the the first picture of a black hole you have seen all over the news, courtesy of Dr. Katie Bouman. We are thrilled to see the wave of recognition for this young #WomenInScience.